Wednesday, 18 September 2013

A Chocolate Gift

In the post yesterday I received a welcome surprise... a thank you note from the sailing summer camp I am a leader on complete with a chocolate bar!


I was touched, and as I was rather peckish at the time I tucked straight into the chocolate. That got me thinking. Why did I value the chocolate bar so much? If the thank you note had included the cash value of the bar I would have been rather puzzled (it's just not the done thing) and maybe even insulted. I certainly would not have felt as appreciated as I did as I devoured the Milky Way.

Tons of research has shown that material gifts are appreciated more than the cash. This is strange; cash gives us more flexibility. A recent paper by Kube, Marechal and Puppe (2011) concludes that it really is the thought that counts. The more thought that has gone into a gift, the more we appreciate it, almost regardless of how useful the gift is to us.

So there we go; if anyone feels like thanking me in the near future... send a chocolate bar...

Thursday, 12 September 2013

Winter Fuel Payment


In the UK everyone over the age of 60 is given the Winter Fuel Payment each year by the government. ('Winter Fuel' refers to heating and electricity costs.) Over the last 10 years the Winter Fuel Payment has varied between £200 and £250 per person over 60, with the payment for those over 80 varying between £300 and £400. The Winter Fuel Payment is usually paid in one lump sum in November or December. There are no legal requirements or official guidelines over how the Winter Fuel Payment should be spent by the recipients.

On average, what percentage of the Winter Fuel Payment do you think is spent on fuel? 

Imagine the hypothetical scenario where everything stayed the same, but the Winter Fuel Payment was called 'The Annual Payment'. On average, what percentage of the Winter Fuel Payment (now called The Annual Payment) do you think would be spent on fuel?


The answers are 41% and 3%, respectively! (according to Beatty, Blow, Crossley and O'Dea, 2011) The label 'Winter Fuel' alone causes 38% of the Payment to be spent on fuel. This is called the labelling effect and it is another example of non-fungibility.

Does this information change whether you think pensioners should receive the Winter Fuel Payment?

Wednesday, 11 September 2013

Does the Child Benefit?

In the UK all parents receive Child Benefit from the government (equivalent to Child Tax Credit in the US). It's worth £20.30 per week for the eldest child and £13.40 per week for other children. The government spends 1% of GNP of Child Benefit. So it seems relevant to ask how Child Benefit is actually used by parents...

a) Parents spend a greater proportion of the Child Benefit on their children than they do with other sources of income
b) Parents spend the same proportion of the Child Benefit on their children as they do with other sources of income
c) Parents spend a lower proportion of the Child Benefit on their children than they do with other sources of income

(This data is accurate for the years previous to the recent change: all parents got the whole Child Benefit regardless of income)




The answer is c!

Blow, Walker and Zhu (2012) found that parents spent less of the Child Benefit on their kids than they do with other sources of income. Does this mean that British parents are uncaring?

Well, it gets worse... Parents typically spend nearly half of the Child Benefit on alcohol!


Oh dear. That's what children drive you to. 
- My Dad

But, in fairness, upon delving into the data Blow et al. discovered that parents have already insured their children's consumption out of primary sources of income. So an alternative explanation of the data is that parents don't count the Child Benefit when doing their budgeting and then treat it as an extra to be spent frivolously, safe in the knowledge that their children are cared for.

This is non-fungibility, but just not in the expected direction. The label 'Child Benefit' has a rather perverse effect. 

So, what do you think, does this prove Child Benefit should be axed?

Saturday, 7 September 2013

Easy Money


Does the way you spend your money differ according to how it came your way?

More specifically, are you more or less prudent with income that you didn't directly earn (such as an inheritance or a government grant)?


A recent paper by Christiaensen and Pan (2012) analysed household spending in rural China and Tanzania and found that different sources of income are used differently. 

Earned income is more likely to be spent on food staples or education, while unearned income is more likely to be spent on more luxury goods such as alcohol, tobacco or clothing. While money is quantitatively the same, it is viewed as qualitatively different. This non-fungibility has implications for whether government money is distributed by employment generating programmes or cash transfers.

So have a think, are you less careful with unearned income? Could you better manage your finances by paying more attention to how you spend 'easy' money?